Logo for Joe Sobran's newsletter: Sobran's -- The Real News of the Month

 Orwell’s Fable, Bush’s Reality 

November 15, 2005 
Nothing looks as dated as yesterday’s futurism. If you watch the old sci-fi film Things to Come, made in 1936 and based on an H.G. Wells novel, you’re struck by the naiveté of what it prophesied for 1970. It envisioned all sorts of marvelous new inventions, huge shiny stainless steel gadgets, but it didn’t foresee what really happened: compact innovations like the transistor, which, inconceivable in 1936, eliminated the sheer bulk of so many everyday appliances and made countless others possible. Today's column is "Orwell's Fable, Bush's Reality" -- Read Joe's columns the day he writes them.Who ever dreamed we’d be able to listen to Beethoven symphonies on an airplane?

In another novel, Wells imagined an invention that has become a staple of science fiction: the time machine, allowing passengers to visit both past and future. Even modern electronics hasn’t advanced a step closer to this one, because it’s metaphysically impossible. Transistors can’t do much about that.

Yesterday’s optimism about the future now looks as superstitious as astrology. But so, in some ways, does yesterday’s pessimism. George Orwell gave us a bleak picture of tyranny to come in his novel Nineteen Eighty-Four. It’s a great fable, full of profound insights and warnings that remain pertinent. But, as a blueprint of the form tyranny would actually take, we have to say it got some key features wrong.

Orwell envisioned a super-Stalinist socialist society, efficiently ruled by an “Inner Party” of diabolical cunning. Winston Smith, the book’s hapless hero, runs afoul of the Party when he begins to dissent from the lies of the Party line, and his torturer, O’Brien, explains how the system really works with Machiavellian intelligence. It turns out that the Party has engineered even Winston’s dissent! Not only political freedom but free will itself has been abolished.

It’s a nightmarish idea, all right, but not even Kim Jong Il’s North Korea has managed to approximate it. Orwell himself was too sensible to believe his comprehensive dystopia could ever be realized in fact.

[Breaker quote for Orwell's Fable, Bush's Reality: Big Brother? Not exactly]If we mistake the melodramatic fable for literal prediction, as too many of Orwell’s readers have done, we’re apt to become too complacent to recognize the forms tyranny actually takes, or to recognize the tyrants we actually face. In fact it sounds overwrought to call the contemporary U.S. Government tyrannical, since President Bush isn’t even a reasonable facsimile of Stalin, Kim, or Mao, let alone Orwell’s O’Brien.

Bush, in fact, claims to have delivered us from tyranny by toppling Saddam Hussein before we reached the mushroom cloud stage. He now complains that the Democrats in Congress who voted for war with Iraq are dishonestly withdrawing their support and trying to “rewrite history.”

But as E.J. Dionne of the Washington Post reminds us, Bush himself capitalized on post–9/11 hysteria and the imminent 2002 elections, using dubious military intelligence (which he also distorted), to bully critics and political opponents into compliance. Now that the Democrats, like most attentive Americans, are having second thoughts, he accuses them of making “baseless attacks” in suggesting that he “manipulated the intelligence and misled the American people” in order to get his war.

No, Bush doesn’t much resemble the villain of Nineteen Eighty-Four. Nor does his “brain,” Karl Rove. But their campaign to demonize Saddam Hussein and engineer a virtually unanimous public opinion can only remind us of Orwell’s “two-minute hate” against the phantom enemy Goldstein, who also turns out to be an invention of the ruling Party; their huge apparatus of “homeland security” reminds us of Party institutions like the Ministry of Truth; and of course their language has much in common with Newspeak. All this is alarming enough; we needn’t press the analogies too far. Bush isn’t Big Brother.

What Orwell’s great fable omits is the gradualism of actual tyranny. He shows us an imaginary tyranny that is already complete. And for the purposes of a cautionary fable, this is fine.

But in the real world, tyranny comes on tiptoe, by stealthy steps and often clumsy improvisation, and it’s usually exercised by men who, unlike the cold-blooded intellectual O’Brien, don’t even realize what they’re doing. They may sincerely think of themselves as enemies of tyranny rather than its agents. And instead of devising new institutions of mass control, they may merely take advantage of arrangements they find already in place.

Joseph Sobran

Copyright © 2005 by the Griffin Internet Syndicate,
a division of Griffin Communications
This column may not be reprinted in print or
Internet publications without express permission
of Griffin Internet Syndicate

small Griffin logo
Send this article to a friend.

Recipient’s e-mail address:
(You may have multiple e-mail addresses; separate them by spaces.)

Your e-mail address:

Enter a subject for your e-mail:

Mailarticle © 2001 by Gavin Spomer
Archive Table of Contents

Current Column

Return to the SOBRANS home page.

FGF E-Package columns by Joe Sobran, Sam Francis, Paul Gottfried, and others are available in a special e-mail subscription provided by the Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation. Click here for more information.

Search This Site

Search the Web     Search SOBRANS

What’s New?

Articles and Columns by Joe Sobran
 FGF E-Package “Reactionary Utopian” Columns 
  Wanderer column (“Washington Watch”) 
 Essays and Articles | Biography of Joe Sobran | Sobran’s Cynosure 
 The Shakespeare Library | The Hive
 WebLinks | Books by Joe 
 Subscribe to Joe Sobran’s Columns 

Other FGF E-Package Columns and Articles
 Sam Francis Classics | Paul Gottfried, “The Ornery Observer” 
 Mark Wegierski, “View from the North” 
 Chilton Williamson Jr., “At a Distance” 
 Kevin Lamb, “Lamb amongst Wolves” 
 Subscribe to the FGF E-Package 

Products and Gift Ideas
Back to the home page 


SOBRANS and Joe Sobran’s columns are available by subscription. Details are available on-line; or call 800-513-5053; or write Fran Griffin.

Reprinted with permission
This page is copyright © 2005 by The Vere Company
and may not be reprinted in print or
Internet publications without express permission
of The Vere Company.